AFTERWORD

Chapter 33

Twenty-Nine

Overview

In a secret meeting, Tonner and his group debate whether to join Ostencour's proposal for resistance against the Carryx. When the librarian interrupts and leads them to a newly assigned alcove lab—the former quarters of the Night Drinkers—equipped with advanced scientific instruments, the debate gains new momentum. Later, Dafyd privately confronts Ostencour about the futility and danger of rebellion, but Ostencour argues that human resistance is inevitable regardless of the odds.

Summary

Tonner's group gathers in their lab as Jessyn and Synnia present Ostencour's proposal for armed resistance against the Carryx. Opinions divide sharply: Campar and Else argue it is suicide, while Rickar and Synnia insist they cannot accept permanent captivity. Tonner initially resists but begins to see potential in conducting biological research on the Carryx, starting with Dafyd gathering samples from the librarian. The debate is interrupted when the librarian arrives without soldiers, creating fear among the group. Instead of executions, it leads them to a newly assigned alcove containing the equipment and organisms from the dead Night Drinkers' lab, telling them they must adapt organisms from one world to nourish those from another. The group begins cataloging the advanced equipment—imaging decks, microscopes, protein libraries—while Synnia interprets the assignment as a sign supporting Ostencour's plan. Later, Dafyd visits Ostencour privately in his quarters. He challenges the resistance plan as futile, warning that failure could result in the Carryx destroying not only the humans in the prison but also Anjiin itself. Ostencour, remaining calm and centered, dismisses these concerns, arguing that human resistance is inevitable and that he merely wants to inflict damage before the inevitable loss. He reframes Dafyd's caution as grief-driven cowardice, insisting that some will rebel no matter what, and he intends to be prepared when they do.

Characters

  • TonnerLead scientist and group member wrestling with whether to participate in resistance; begins to see biological research possibilities as a first step
  • JessynPresents Ostencour's resistance proposal to the group; appears cautious about security risks in the new lab assignment
  • SynniaAdvocates passionately for resistance, motivated by grief over Ostencour; interprets the new lab assignment as a sign supporting rebellion
  • CamparArgues against resistance as suicidal, questions the feasibility and wisdom of fighting the Carryx
  • ElseAgrees with Campar against immediate action; shows emotional tension at Tonner's intellectual engagement with the resistance idea
  • RickarArgues that waiting for a safe time to rebel is equivalent to accepting captivity; keeps watch at the new lab with a crowbar
  • DafydRemains mostly silent during group debate; later privately confronts Ostencour about the dangers of rebellion and questions the plan's moral implications
  • The LibrarianThe Carryx representative who summons the group and assigns them the new lab space with organisms and equipment from the Night Drinkers
  • Urrys OstencourSecurity officer proposing armed resistance; meets privately with Dafyd to argue that human rebellion is inevitable and he intends to be part of it
  • JellitAssociated with resistance planning; mentioned as located elsewhere in the prison
  • MerrolAssociated with Jellit; mentioned as located elsewhere in the prison
  • AllstinAssociated with Jellit's group; mentioned as located elsewhere in the prison