62. The One Who Killed Promises

Kaladin remains imprisoned while Dalinar visits to assure him of his eventual release and pardon. During their conversation, Kaladin learns that Roshone—the man responsible for his family's downfall in Hearthstone—was exiled rather than imprisoned for his crimes, fueling Kaladin's growing resentment toward the kingdom's justice system and Elhokar.

Kaladin endures his cell, struggling with the confinement despite adequate conditions, and performs exercises to maintain strength. Syl reveals that a Cryptic spren was present at his fight and that Cryptics are searching for someone—possibly another Surgebinder. Dalinar arrives unannounced and instructs Kaladin to view his imprisonment as a duty; he promises that Elhokar is cooling off and will issue a formal pardon within days, with Kaladin reinstated to his position. Kaladin expresses doubt that the king will ever release him, citing the fate of silversmiths imprisoned under Elhokar's rule. Dalinar admits this was an error involving a man named Roshone, a minor lighteyes and former citylord of Hearthstone who influenced the crown prince. Roshone had caused Kaladin's family's suffering and poverty, leading to Tien's conscription. Dalinar explains that Roshone was exiled rather than imprisoned because he was connected to powerful allies and Highprince Sadeas, and because mercy toward him was deemed politically necessary. Kaladin struggles to accept this injustice. Dalinar defends his decision to place Kaladin in his current position, saying his instincts told him Kaladin could help change the kingdom. He warns Kaladin that change will come through distinguishing himself and proving darkeyes can lead, not through reckless defiance. After Dalinar leaves, Kaladin's despair deepens into a dark conviction that Elhokar must die for the kingdom's good, viewing the king as a festering wound requiring removal.